The News Wheel
No Comments

Are WeatherTech FloorLiners Really Worth It?

Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page

Do the custom-fit, high-end car mats warrant their prices?

Weathertech Floorliners review car floor mats rubber heavy duty worth it for price difference buy purchase

Photo: The News Wheel

Many gearheads swear that American company WeatherTech is the pinnacle interior protection, particularly the company’s famous FloorLiners. But thrifty consumers are wondering how much better these are than the one-size-fits-all mats you can buy at Wal-Mart for a fraction of the price.

Recently, The News Wheel checked out a set of WeatherTech FloorLiners for a 2014 Hyundai Elantra sent to us by After a thorough hands-on test and inspection, we decided that these FloorLiners did indeed live up to their reputation.

Struggle to Keep Your Car Clean? You may find these car-cleaning hacks helpful

Weathertech Floorliners review car floor mats rubber heavy duty worth it for price difference view Hyundai Elantra

WeatherTech Liners rise up to cover the sides of the footwell
Photo: The News Wheel

How do WeatherTech FloorLiners work?

Unlike other aftermarket car floor mats, WeatherTech uses advanced DigitalFit technology to scan and measure the dimensions and curvature of every single vehicle, even down to the precise year and body configuration (e.g., coupe vs. sedan). Using that information, designers craft customized liners to fill any vehicle’s footwell using a rigid, high-density material.

To install WeatherTech FloorLiners, remove the original cloth mats and thoroughly clean the floor before fitting the replacement in. The liner should snap into the same anchors that the original mats did. But unlike traditional mats, FloorLiners rise up to cover the sides of the footwell. Because of their shape and water-resistant material, these liners aim to keep mud, water, and dirt from getting underneath, where they have the potential to damage the cabin’s carpet permanently.

Weathertech Floorliners review car floor mats rubber heavy duty worth it for price difference back seat

The back row liner is one long piece for both seats
Photo: The News Wheel

Are WeatherTech FloorLiners really that good?

It seems obvious for worksite trucks and off-roading utility vehicles to have WeatherTech FloorLiners to protect against extreme messes, but they might not seem necessary for your average urban sedan or suburban crossover. That’s what I always believed, so I was surprised to see what a difference WeatherTech FloorLiners made in keeping the car clean.

Even heavy-duty mats can let water and dirt slip underneath, which you’ll uncover the next time you pull them out to vacuum the car. When we pulled the Hyundai Elantra’s WeatherTech FloorLiners out, there wasn’t any more dirt underneath than there had been when we installed the liners.

The most common criticism I’ve heard of about WeatherTech FloorLiners is that although they claim to fit flush against the sides of the footwell, there are still gaps.

When I installed these liners, there were indeed small spaces showing in certain areas, particularly on the sides. But over a month of use, the liners gradually settled into place and those gaps essentially closed. Plus, nothing seemed to get inside those gaps. So, unless so leave your car door open so the interior gets drenched (in which case, dirt in the gap won’t be your main concern), you should be fine.

More Car Accessory Advice: Why you should buy winter windshield wiper blades

Weathertech Floorliners review car floor mats rubber heavy duty worth it for price difference OEM comparison

WeatherTech Floorliner for a 2014 Hyundai Elantra vs. rubber heavy-duty mat for a 2014 Hyundai Veloster
Photo: The News Wheel

WeatherTech vs. heavy-duty OEM floor mats: Which are better?

If you’re a traditionalist, you may favor buying floormats directly from your car’s OEM instead of a third-party manufacturer like WeatherTech. For my Hyundai Veloster, I choose OEM mats over WeatherTech Floorliners, so I was able to compare the two options side-by-side.

Heavy duty OEM rubber mats are weightier and thicker than liners, providing a cushion while keeping the mat from sliding around. They’re definitely an improvement over the original carpeted mats. But, they don’t protect from spills, dust, and tiny debris like liners do—especially behind the pedals and against the sill plate. Only WeatherTech Floorliners can do that.

As one of our reviewers put it, “They’re not mats; they’re a second interior lining for your car. Once you install them, it’s like they’re not even there. They basically become the car’s new and improved footwell.”

WeatherTech FloorLiners are a must for anyone who wants to protect the interior of their car and make cleanup much easier.

To save money, purchase WeatherTech FloorLiners for any vehicle through PartCatalog, which guarantees the lowest prices and free shipping.

Disclaimer: Products provided for review by PartCatalog